Why Everyone Performs The Nutcracker in December
Share
Every December, it happens in practically every city with a ballet company: the Christmas tree goes up on stage, the toy soldiers march, and the Sugar Plum Fairy dances. The Nutcracker has become so tied to Christmas that it feels as if it must always have been that way.
It wasn't. The ballet premiered a week before Christmas in 1892 — and then spent decades not being a Christmas tradition at all.
It starts on Christmas Eve — that part was always there
The story itself is a Christmas story from the first page. It comes from E. T. A. Hoffmann's 1816 tale "The Nutcracker and the Mouse King", retold by Alexandre Dumas in 1844, and it opens on Christmas Eve: a family party, a Christmas tree, and a godfather's gift — a wooden nutcracker doll — that comes to life after midnight. The tree grows, the toy soldiers fight the Mouse King, and Clara (or Marie, depending on the production) travels to the Land of Sweets.
So the Christmas setting was never the puzzle. The puzzle is why a ballet with that setting took so long to become the Christmas ballet.
The premiere was a flop — the suite was the hit
Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky's Nutcracker premiered on 18 December 1892 at the Imperial Mariinsky Theatre in St Petersburg, as the second half of a double bill with his one-act opera Iolanta. Marius Petipa had begun the choreography, but fell ill that August, and his assistant Lev Ivanov took it over. The first performance was not deemed a success: audiences liked the Christmas party and the battle in Act One, but Act Two is mostly a parade of dances with almost no story, and many people found it unconvincing.
What did succeed, immediately, was the music on its own. Before the premiere, Tchaikovsky had pulled eight numbers out of the score as a concert suite — and that suite was encored, number by number, at its first performances. For years, people knew the tunes long before they knew the ballet: the March, the Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy, the Waltz of the Flowers. The ballet itself was performed complete only rarely.
Listen for the celesta in the Sugar Plum Fairy's dance — that bell-like sound was brand new. The instrument had been invented in Paris in 1886, Tchaikovsky heard it there in 1891, and he was so taken with it that he asked his publishers to order one and keep it secret, so that Rimsky-Korsakov and Glazunov would not use it first.
America made it December
The turn towards Christmas happened in America, and it happened in stages. The first full performance outside Russia was in London in 1934. The first complete American Nutcracker was danced by San Francisco Ballet on Christmas Eve, 1944 — and that company has performed it every Christmas season since.
Then came George Balanchine. His Nutcracker for New York City Ballet premiered in February 1954 — February, not December — but he made it an annual event, put children at the centre of it (eighty of them, which meant hundreds of relatives in the audience), and CBS broadcast it three days before Christmas in 1957 and on Christmas Day in 1958. By the 1960s, the complete ballet had taken off as an annual Christmas tradition across the country, and it has never let go.
That is also why the tradition is strongest in North America: in much of the rest of the world, The Nutcracker is still performed outside Christmas too. Here, December claimed it — because the story is set at Christmas, because a ballet full of children is a family outing, and because, once Balanchine showed it could fill a theatre every year, every company wanted one of its own.
Why it still works
Part of it is the music, which most of us knew before we ever saw the ballet — from the suite, from Fantasia in 1940, from every advert and film that has borrowed the Sugar Plum Fairy. Part of it is the ritual: the same story, the same tree growing, the same snow, once a year, marking that another year has passed. And part of it is practical: it is one of the few ballets where a whole dance school can take part, from the smallest mice to the Sugar Plum Fairy herself.
If you are going this December — as a dancer, a parent in the audience, or a music teacher taking a group — the Tchaikovsky Nutcracker tee is the one to wear to it. It is in the Holiday collection with the rest of the season's pieces, and the full range is in all the t-shirts.
Our tees are made to order, which takes 5–10 business days of production before shipping — so order early in December for Christmas delivery. Shipping is free worldwide, and every order is tracked.
And if you want the other half of the December story — the choral one — we wrote about why Handel's Messiah became a holiday tradition here.